Moneyzine
/Investment Guides /Mutual Fund Ratings

Mutual Fund Ratings

Moneyzine Editor
Author: 
Moneyzine Editor
5 mins
September 20th, 2023
Advertiser Disclosure

In this article, we're going to cover the topic of mutual fund ratings. This discussion will include an explanation of the premier fund rating system as published by Morningstar. We're also going to discuss some of the problems investors need to be aware of when using a rating system, as well as the available alternatives.

Morningstar Mutual Fund Ratings

Investors new to the stock market are often attracted to the features mutual funds have to offer. The challenge then becomes determining which funds to pick. Perhaps the best known ratings system comes from the company Morningstar, which has been in business for over 30 years, specializing in the performance rating of mutual funds.

The Morningstar rating system is based on a star ranking classification. Each fund is assigned a rating of its performance versus an assigned risk peer group. The fund can earn a rating from one to five stars. The system is meant to be intuitive for the investor: Pick a mutual fund with a five-star rating. If choosing a mutual fund were that simple, everyone would be rich.

Unfortunately, the Morningstar system is based on historical performance. The company calculates the star rating by subtracting the fund's risk score from its return score, and plots those points on a curve. The top 10% of funds that provide the highest risk-adjusted return are given the prestigious five-star rating.

Problems with Rating Systems

The fundamental problem with using these types of rating systems is the information is based on historical performance. Ironically, every mutual fund prospectus published has a disclaimer that reads "past performance is not an indication of future performance." The Securities and Exchange Commission makes mutual funds put that disclaimer on a prospectus for a good reason. It is absolutely true.

Past Performance

Just because a mutual fund performed well in the past does not mean it will perform well in the future. In fact, it might mean the fund will under-perform the market over the next several years.

Most mutual funds specialize in some manner. They do this to differentiate themselves from other offerings, and this approach also provides the investor with options. For example, a fund might specialize in creating portfolios of stocks consisting of companies that make personal computer equipment.

For many years, the price of these technology stocks accelerated well ahead of the market. The Morningstar ratings for many of these technology-focused mutual funds would have been five stars. But as history reveals, the technology stock funds suffered for the next five to seven years. This is a clear example of the problem with the Morningstar rating system. Smart investors realize they should not blindly purchase shares of a mutual fund just because they carry a five-star rating.

This is not to say the Morningstar rating system has no value. Past performance is certainly one indication of a well-managed fund. This rating system can also be used as a primary filter when developing an overall investment strategy. For example, the rating system can be used as an introduction to prospective funds. However, the rating would not be the deciding factor, or the only factor, to use when selecting and / or researching a mutual fund.

Alternate Approaches to Rate Mutual Funds

Investing one's hard earned money should never be about short cuts. If money is going to be placed in a mutual fund, there is no substitute for conducting research ahead of time. It's easy enough to develop a comprehensive rating system based on information such as:

  • Financial Objectives: includes the mutual fund's fit with the investor's overall financial objective. This includes long versus short term investment timeframes, the need for income versus growth, as well as contingencies.

  • Fees: includes costs such as front-loads, management fees, and expense ratios. These fees can severely reduce a fund's overall return on investment, especially when timeframes are less than five years.

  • Risk Profile: this includes measures such as the fund's bear market rank, which is a measure of volatility during market downturns. This can also include the investor's personal risk profile.

  • Historical Returns: as just mentioned, history may not be a good predictor of future success, but it can provide insights into the fund's performance relative to its peers.

Many of these same concepts are discussed in our four-part series on buying mutual funds.

Contrary Indicators

Another way to use fund ratings is to consider them as a possible contrary indicator. For example, the investor might want to take a closer look at all of the five star funds and try to decipher a pattern:

  • Did these funds contain large capitalization stocks?

  • Did they provide portfolios of an industrial sector that may have experienced a run up in prices?

After considering these factors, the investor or analyst might decide to avoid a certain sector of the economy in the immediate future.

It's important to take that first step. Examine the rating of a mutual fund, but keep in mind that an over-performing fund is very likely to slow down in the future. Finally, as an alternative strategy, take a closer look at quality funds that have under-performed the market. Careful research might conclude the time has come for another sector of the economy to start moving ahead once again.


About the Author - Mutual Fund Ratings


Explore Investing Further

Trading has never been easier, thanks to the rise of online platforms that enable you to buy and sell various assets at the click of a button. But with so many options available, it can be challenging to decide which platform is right for you.
Looking for a way to avoid swap fees while trading forex?
Below listed are the small reviews of the top 10 ETF brokers available across the United States.
Our top beginner's pick for copy trading is eToro. Read on for more details, plus seven good alternatives.
Swing trading stocks can be a great way for investors to take advantage of short-term stock market movements and gain significant returns. If you're interested in swing trading, the key to success lies in selecting the right stocks to buy and sell quickly for a profit.
The table below lists the best stock picks under $2, listed on public exchanges.
The table below lists the best stock picks under $1, listed both on public and OTC exchanges.
This section will highlight the best EV-trading penny stocks available in the United States.
The demand for sustainable energy has grown rapidly in recent years. This has resulted in increased scrutiny of the automotive market. As a result, the electric vehicle (EV) industry has made significant advancements.
Intelligent Bio Solutions Inc. is a life sciences company, founded in 2016 with headquarters in New York and is engaged in performing diagnostic tests, real-time monitoring, and non-invasive surgery for its patients. The firm has developed a CoV-2 Biosensor, which can be used in RNA virus detection.
Hour Loop was founded in 2013 with headquarters in Redmond, Washington. It’s an online retailer involved in e-commerce in the United States that hit the public markets on Jan 7th of 2022. The company sells home/garden decor, electronic products, kitchenware, and apparel through walmart.com, amazon.com, and hourloop.com.

Related Content

How to Make a Million Dollars in 10 Years
Truthfully, this title should actually be “How to Make a Million Dollars in 10 Years Without Going Into Debt", but that is just getting a little too winded for my liking. It’s true though!
March 26th, 2024
How to Apply Maslow’s Hierarchy to Your Money This Year
You might vaguely remember your psychology teacher talking about Maslow. He pointed at a picture of a triangle as you nodded off in the back of the school room.
March 27th, 2024
How to Tackle Multiple Savings Goals
When there’s only so much money to go around, there are often multiple savings goals competing for your money. Think of the young professional who’d like to get a more reliable car, buy a house, and save for retirement. Or consider the young family that’s saving for college, retirement, and a bigger house.
March 22nd, 2024
The Countdown to Early Retirement: 10 Expenses to Eliminate
Dreaming of waving goodbye to the daily grind five years ahead of schedule? The road to early retirement is paved with more than good intentions; it requires a meticulously crafted strategy with surprising twists. It's not solely about what you should be doing—like diligently saving a portion of your income or investing wisely—but also about what you need to stop doing.
March 22nd, 2024
Biden Or Trump: Who Is Better For The Economy And Stocks?
Yup. This is one of those articles. It's an election year, and here in the U.S., we get to decide which old dude who’s been alive long enough to remember when there were only 48 states in the U.S. will be the leader of the free world.
March 19th, 2024

Contributors

Moneyzine 2024. All Rights Reserved.